LET'S GET READY TO RUMBLE It looks like -- and you can never quite tell -- that the Senate will finally be taking up energy legislation next week. As you know, our current energy system is big time dependent on fossil and nuclear fuels. And the gist of the debate is do we continue down this slimy dirty road or do we take cleaner, greener path. And if the pre-debate debate is any indication this should be a bruiser. The two standout controversies in the debate are a proposal to allow oil and gas drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge and raising fuel-efficiency standards. Controversy over the refuge has turned into a triumph of spin over science -- and both sides are guilty of cavalier commentary littered with selective facts. Drilling proponents exaggerate how much oil the U.S. would recover from the refuge and the supposed reduction in foreign oil dependence. And we environmentalists may be shouting catastrophe loudly but not correctly. But at the end of the day we've still got to ask ourselves if sucking more oil -- from remote refuges, remote countries or anywhere -- makes sense. Then there's fuel-efficiency standards. The White House has been pounding Democratic proposals to raise the fuel-efficiency standards for cars and trucks. And this week they slammed fuel-efficiency standards by connecting them to thousands of deaths. That's right, the White House says that stricter fuel-efficiency standards would lead to -- lord have mercy -- smaller cars and thus more traffic deaths. The White House seems to be completely ignoring the fact that higher fuel-efficiency standards would save more oil than we receive from Persian Gulf imports, offshore drilling in California, and potential deposits in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge combined. Sen. John Kerry (D-Mass) -- who wrote the fuel-economy plan -- dismissed the White House's statement as "hysterical distortion" and "scare tactics" promoted by the auto industry. Your senator is deciding right now what road to take us down on these two important issues. It's up to you to tell them whether you want the dirty, grimy low road or the cleaner, greener highroad.
|