Governor Hochul: No More Taxpayer Money For NYRA
The New York Racing Association (NYRA) is asking for nearly half a BILLION dollars in state-backed financing to renovate Belmont Park - the deadliest track in New York State.
NYRA is already receiving $130 Million a year in casino support payments.
It's time to tell Governor Hochul to end this Massive Subsidization to a dying industry!
HERE ARE THE FACTS:
Belmont’s attendance is down a staggering 88%
For 18 years the state has subsidized horseracing with billions. And since 1978, attendance has dropped almost 90%. With the exception of the Belmont Stakes day and Saratoga’s brief 40-day meet, stands are virtually empty at all of NY’s 11 racetracks. A recent Marist Poll found more than 90% of New Yorkers have no plans to ever attend a NY racetrack. 78% of wagers on races held in NY come from other states, with those states collecting the wagering tax, not NY. Empty tracks have been a disaster for NY’s treasury and created substantial job losses over the years.
Horse racing pays almost no gambling taxes to New York
New York’s lottery, mobile sports betting and casinos pay billions to the state every 12 months. Shockingly, the New York Racing Association (NYRA) pays only $8 million in annual wagering taxes to NY while receiving more than $130 million in state support every year. NYRA pays no NYS income tax, no City of NY general corporation taxes, no sales tax for million-dollar racehorses and no rent for Aqueduct, Belmont and Saratoga. NYS doesn’t verify racing’s claims of jobs or economic impact. The “economic activity” projected for Belmont Park is speculative at best.
NYRA can’t even pay franchise fees to the state
If the financial markets won’t fund a new Belmont Park, New York shouldn’t either. NYRA has a long, troubled history of bankruptcy, criminality and fiscal mismanagement. Following an unprecedented 2008 bankruptcy bailout, and 14 years of massive VLT support, NYRA still can’t even pay franchise fees to the state—which once totaled $16 million annually.
30-year debt is requested…but NYRA’s contract ends in 10 years
Ironically, NYRA will pay the debt with state support from NY's video lottery terminals—a successful gambling business funding a weak and risky NYRA business model. Worse yet, NYRA's contract with NY ends 2 decades before the debt is to be paid off. It's reckless to assume that new bidders for the racing franchise in 2033 will agree to inherit 20 years of enormous financial obligations. This is a dishonest strategy by NYRA to extend their franchise. Additionally, issuing 30-year bonds for a new track, when younger generations show no interest in racing, is fiscally irresponsible.
More horses die at Belmont than any other track in New York
Belmont is a racehorse killing field. In the last 8 years, 480 young horses have died at Aqueduct and Belmont. As these 2 tracks merge their racing schedules into a new Belmont Park, it is estimated 1,800 more horses will die by the time the 30-year bonds are paid. NY State should end their financial support of this cruel and inhumane gambling boondoggle.