Ben-Gvir's new private militia is NOT a win for democracy

President Joe Biden

As we’ve seen mainstream U.S. media outlets report “a victory” for Israeli protesters, a huge story has been buried.

While Netanyahu announced a delay to his proposed judiciary overhaul this week, most outlets are leaving out the concessions he made to get there: more violence against the Palestinian people.

Netanyahu has agreed to establish a new armed battalion under the control of Itamar Ben-Gvir, the ultranationalist national security minister who openly supports the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians. This new militia will pick up the mantle of the settler vigilantes who hunted for Palestinians in Lyd, Haifa, and other cities during the May 2021 Unity Intifada. Ben-Gvir already has an immense amount of power over police forces that regularly inflict violence on Palestinians. Giving him control over what is essentially a private militia would have even more grave consequences for Palestinian lives.

Tell Biden this sinister deal to create a private militia for a man already convicted of racist incitement is NOT A WIN for democracy. Israel has never been a democracy and this directly makes the problem worse.

Instead of condemning this alarming deal, Biden's administration is hosting Netanyahu at the White House’s “Summit for Democracy'' starting this evening. And earlier today, the U.S. Ambassador to Israel told Israeli outlets that Netanyahu could be invited to the White House after Passover - signaling that a long withheld invitation could be forthcoming. These moves together, signal that Biden sees this deal as acceptable and sufficient for resuming the status quo.

Biden is directly giving Netanyahu moral cover and cosigning this exchange of a paramilitary force led by a genocidal racist as somehow an acceptable compromise to preserve the illusion of Israeli democracy.

Itanar Ben-Gvir has a long history of supporting extreme racist, anti-Palestinian violence and it is especially disturbing that he will be leading this force.

In an oft-quoted 2011 interview, Ben-Gvir defended his support for Baruch Goldstein, the Israeli American who killed 29 Palestinians while they prayed at a mosque in Hebron. Ben-Gvir called Goldstein a “hero” and a “righteous man.”

The public outrage over the judicial plan is due to many Israelis seeing their own rights threatened for the first time. Meanwhile Palestinian rights have never been upheld by Israeli courts. In fact, what many people don’t realize is that Israel doesn’t have a constitution at all. Why? Because if Israel had a constitution it would have had to accept equality for all before the law and that would inhibit Israel’s central state project: settler-colonialism.

In many ways, Ben-Gvir’s militia has long existed in the settlements where armed settlers routinely carry out violence against Palestinians with the protection of the Israeli military. The new proposed militia would take this a step further by formalizing the arrangement within ‘48 and providing members with greater access to weapons and resources.

Our tax dollars should not be funding apartheid and ethnic cleansing. Our tax dollars should not be funding armed militias. Tell Biden now that this is unacceptable. Add your name now.


To: President Joe Biden
From: [Your Name]

Dear President Biden,

It is long past time for your administration to exert real power to protect Palestinian lives by ending all U.S. military funding to Israel. It is time for you to stop supporting the illusion of Israeli democracy.

We are aware that your administration has spent significant time behind closed doors meeting with Israeli government officials to pressure Prime Minister Netanyahu to back down from his government's plans to weaken the power of the judiciary. While your administration’s efforts went unheeded by Netanyahu, as reported by Politico on March 27, widespread protests in Israel have, for the moment, secured what your administration was unable to accomplish.

The ongoing debates and protests around Netanyahu’s judiciary reforms come at a huge price for Palestinians. To secure the support of his right-wing, religious coalition partners, Netanyahu has offered a new militia to Itamar Ben-Gvir, the ultranationalist national security minister who openly supports the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians. This new militia will pick up the mantle of the settler vigilantes who hunted for Palestinians in Lyd, Haifa and other cities during the May 2021 uprisings. Ben-Gvir already has an immense amount of power over police forces that regularly inflict violence on Palestinians. Giving him control over what is essentially a private militia would have even graver consequences for Palestinian lives.

Instead of condemning this alarming deal, your administration has signaled support by announcing that the White House would host Netanyahu in Washington in the coming months. Announcing this invitation discounts the escalating violence of the Israeli state against Palestinians

Netanyahu is leading a country formally charged with the crime of apartheid and ethnic cleansing and still your administration is hosting him at the White House’s “Summit for Democracy '' on March 29.

Your administration is directly giving Netanyahu moral cover and cosigning this exchange of a paramilitary force led by a genocidal racist as somehow an acceptable compromise to preserve the illusion of Israeli democracy. It’s time for your administration to heed the call of the growing number of young Americans who are demanding that the U.S. end its unconditional support and funding of Israel.