Petition to Urge Governor Bill Lee to Veto SB1930 / HB1871
Governor Bill Lee
The next few days matter because Governor Bill Lee has a very limited window once he receives the bill, just 10 days (excluding Sundays), to decide whether to sign or veto SB1930/HB1871. Once that window closes, the opportunity to stop the bill is gone. This legislation would impose longer, mandatory sentences without considering individual circumstances, impacting people who never intended to take a life. Signing the petition now shows urgent public concern. There is strength in numbers. Join us in calling for fairness and the principle of separate acts, separate facts. Please share with your networks, and join the movement to make change!
To:
Governor Bill Lee
From:
[Your Name]
Dear Governor Lee,
We, the undersigned, respectfully urge you to exercise your veto power on Senate Bill 1930 / House Bill 1871, a measure that would significantly increase punishment for individuals convicted of second-degree murder by mandating sentencing at no less than a Range II level, regardless of individual circumstances. While we recognize the importance of public safety and accountability, this legislation represents a troubling shift toward a more rigid and punitive system that fails to account for the complexity of many cases—particularly those involving felony murder, where individuals may be convicted despite having no intent to kill.
1. Disproportionate Impact on Felony Murder Cases
This bill will inevitably sweep in individuals who did not intend to cause death but were nonetheless convicted under felony murder doctrines. These cases often involve young people, women, survivors, accomplices, or individuals with limited involvement in the underlying offense. By mandating enhanced sentencing ranges, this legislation removes judicial discretion and ensures that people who never intended to take a life will face decades longer in prison.
2. Eliminating Judicial Discretion and Individualized Justice
Judges currently have the ability to consider the nuances of each case—the person’s role, intent, age, background, and potential for rehabilitation. SB1930 strips away that discretion, replacing it with a one-size-fits-all punishment model that undermines fairness and proportionality in sentencing.
3. Increasing Incarceration Without Improving Safety
Your own Criminal Justice Investment Task Force found that Tennessee’s incarceration rate has grown above the national average without corresponding improvements in public safety, noting that the state “has the fourth highest violent crime rate” despite increased imprisonment in comparison with the majority of states who have reduced incarceration and crime simultaneously. The report further concluded that longer sentences and increased time served—not rising crime—are driving prison growth, with individuals spending significantly more time incarcerated due to policy changes . SB1930 would accelerate exactly this trend—expanding sentence lengths without evidence that it will reduce crime.
4. Evidence Shows Overreliance on Incarceration Is Ineffective
Your Task Force also found that 74% of felony prison admissions are for non-person offenses and that incarceration has not been shown to reduce recidivism more effectively than alternatives. These findings underscore a key principle: more punishment does not necessarily equal more safety. Instead, smart justice policies focus resources on truly dangerous individuals while expanding alternatives and rehabilitation for others.
5. Contradiction of Your Clemency Record and Policy Vision
Governor Lee, your administration established this Task Force to promote a more effective and evidence-based system—one focused on reducing recidivism, improving reentry outcomes, and using incarceration more strategically. You have also granted clemency in cases where individuals were over-sentenced or lacked intent to commit violent harm—demonstrating a commitment to fairness and second chances. Signing this bill would move Tennessee in the opposite direction—toward longer, more rigid sentences that your own Task Force found do not improve public safety and instead contribute to prison growth and inefficiency.
6. A Moment to Uphold a Legacy of Second Chances
As we recognize Second Chance Month, the final one under your administration, this is a critical opportunity to reaffirm your commitment to redemption, fairness, and data-driven justice reform. Your Task Force explicitly called for policies that focus resources on high-risk individuals while expanding alternatives and reducing recidivism. SB1930 does the opposite—it broadens punishment without regard to risk, intent, or rehabilitation.
We urge you to stand by your principles, your record, and your own administration’s findings. This bill will lead to longer sentences for individuals who may not have intended harm, exacerbate inequities in the justice system, and undermine Tennessee’s progress toward a smarter, more effective criminal justice system.
For these reasons, we respectfully ask you to veto SB1930 / HB1871.
Sincerely,
Separate Acts, Separate Facts Coalition, and the undersigned: