Petition Opposing Philadelphia SEPTA Hydrogen Bus Project

Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA)

Petition Opposing Philadelphia SEPTA Hydrogen Bus Project

Proposed hydrogen bus fleet threatens public health and safety, fuels climate crisis

We, the undersigned, call upon the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA) to halt the pilot project and future expansion plans for the deployment of hydrogen fuel cell powered buses in Philadelphia and the greater Philadelphia region.

Background:

The Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA) plans to build a hydrogen bus fleet to use for public transport. They are starting with a pilot project using 10 hydrogen fuel cell powered buses beginning in the fall of 2024, testing through to the fall of 2025. They will also test 10 battery-powered electric buses. They will then decide which technology to proceed with, either hydrogen fuel cell or fully electric or both. The pilot program will operate out of the Midvale bus depot located at 2401 Roberts Ave. in Philadelphia.

SEPTA is a partner in the proposed MACH2 Hydrogen Hub and plans to become an “end user” of the hydrogen that MACH2 would produce. For now, SEPTA will buy its hydrogen from PLUG Power, a private company that will truck frozen liquid hydrogen each day from Tennessee. At the Midvale bus depot, the liquid hydrogen will be stored and then warmed to a compressed gas that feeds the fuel cells to power the bus. While in use, the hydrogen fuel cells will be carried in canisters on the roofs of the buses. If they decide to move ahead, SEPTA’s plans are to convert its bus fleet to hydrogen, storing and fueling buses at six of their eight bus depots.

There has been no public participation process in this project. People are unaware of the dangers they will be exposed to because SEPTA has not informed or asked for input from those who would be impacted, keeping the public in the dark. This lacks agency transparency and violates environmental justice principles.

HIGHLY DANGEROUS: Hydrogen gas is highly flammable and potentially explosive. Hydrogen gas is very dangerous to handle, transport, and store, exposing residents and workers to catastrophic risk should there be a release to the air. SEPTA has not published safety protocols or standard operating procedures for the handling of such dangerous substances demonstrating how SEPTA is moving quickly while having little workforce experience handling hydrogen. Will SEPTA be capable of providing the required protection for their workers? Will SEPTA ensure the safety of the public and the communities these hydrogen buses will operate in and around?

NOT SAFE IN POPULATED AREAS: Trucks delivering highly volatile liquid hydrogen would travel ~800 miles to Philadelphia and snake through the City’s streets, jeopardizing the safety of neighborhoods and infrastructure. At build out, a minimum of 47 tank trucks per week would be needed (1 to 2 trucks per week for the pilot) and the liquid hydrogen would be stored, then evaporated to a gas, and delivered as a high-pressure gas to each bus. The dense populations along the truck routes, around the terminals, and the commuter and worker proximity to the project’s infrastructure is not proven to be compatible with hydrogen fuel’s dangers and not proven to be safe.

LEAKS: Hydrogen leaks approximately three times faster than natural gas and five times faster than propane on a volumetric basis. Fires and explosions have occurred in various components of hydrogen systems as a result of leaks that can quickly meet a variety of ignition sources. Leaks also result in emissions that will increase the climate crisis because hydrogen is an indirect greenhouse gas.

INEFFICIENT AND UNPROVEN: Hydrogen fuel cell powered transportation is not proving to be competitive with battery powered electric vehicles in terms of efficiency, performance, and affordability. It is also very new and unproven as a technology. Especially at the proposed scale.

HUGELY EXPENSIVE: SEPTA’s estimated cost of just the installation of the hydrogen infrastructure is between $6.5 million to $16.1 million at each of the six depots.


Sponsored by

To: Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA)
From: [Your Name]

Petition Opposing Philadelphia SEPTA Hydrogen Bus Project

Proposed hydrogen bus fleet threatens public health and safety, fuels climate crisis

We, the undersigned, call upon the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA) to halt the pilot project and future expansion plans for the deployment of hydrogen fuel cell powered buses in Philadelphia and the greater Philadelphia region.

Background:

The Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA) plans to build a hydrogen bus fleet to use for public transport. They are starting with a pilot project using 10 hydrogen fuel cell powered buses beginning in the fall of 2024, testing through to the fall of 2025. They will also test 10 battery-powered electric buses. They will then decide which technology to proceed with, either hydrogen fuel cell or fully electric or both. The pilot program will operate out of the Midvale bus depot located at 2401 Roberts Ave. in Philadelphia.

SEPTA is a partner in the proposed MACH2 Hydrogen Hub and plans to become an “end user” of the hydrogen that MACH2 would produce. For now, SEPTA will buy its hydrogen from PLUG Power, a private company that will truck frozen liquid hydrogen each day from Tennessee. At the Midvale bus depot, the liquid hydrogen will be stored and then warmed to a compressed gas that feeds the fuel cells to power the bus. While in use, the hydrogen gas will be carried in canisters on the roofs of the buses. If they decide to move ahead, SEPTA’s plans are to convert its bus fleet to hydrogen, storing and fueling buses at six of their eight bus depots.

There has been no public participation process in this project. People are unaware of the dangers they will be exposed to because SEPTA has not informed or asked for input from those who would be impacted, keeping the public in the dark. This lacks agency transparency and violates environmental justice principles.

HIGHLY DANGEROUS: Hydrogen gas is highly flammable and potentially explosive. Hydrogen gas is very dangerous to handle, transport, and store, exposing residents and workers to catastrophic risk should there be a release to the air. SEPTA has not published safety protocols or standard operating procedures for the handling of such dangerous substances demonstrating how SEPTA is moving quickly while having little workforce experience handling hydrogen. Will SEPTA be capable of providing the required protection for their workers? Will SEPTA ensure the safety of the public and the communities these hydrogen buses will operate in and around?

NOT SAFE IN POPULATED AREAS: Trucks delivering highly volatile liquid hydrogen would travel ~800 miles to Philadelphia and snake through the City’s streets, jeopardizing the safety of neighborhoods and infrastructure. At build out, a minimum of 47 tank trucks per week would be needed (1 to 2 trucks per week for the pilot) and the liquid hydrogen would be stored, then evaporated to a gas, and delivered as a high-pressure gas to each bus. The dense populations along the truck routes, around the terminals, and the commuter and worker proximity to the project’s infrastructure is not proven to be compatible with hydrogen fuel’s dangers and not proven to be safe.

LEAKS: Hydrogen leaks approximately three times faster than natural gas and five times faster than propane on a volumetric basis. Fires and explosions have occurred in various components of hydrogen systems as a result of leaks that can quickly meet a variety of ignition sources. Leaks also result in emissions that will increase the climate crisis because hydrogen is an indirect greenhouse gas.

INEFFICIENT AND UNPROVEN: Hydrogen fuel cell powered transportation is not proving to be competitive with battery powered electric vehicles in terms of efficiency, performance, and affordability. It is also very new and unproven as a technology. Especially at the proposed scale.

HUGELY EXPENSIVE: SEPTA’s estimated cost of just the installation of the hydrogen infrastructure is between $6.5 million to $16.1 million at each of the six depots.